A clean, well-lit place to vent
Please feel free to contribute to this frequently-updated forum, which posts selected commentary on our favorite comic strip. If you’d like your critique to be posted, please note that civility, if not approbation, counts. Click here to submit a comment.
You forgot to mention that the middle-aged male state legislator would also be against a health care decision being made by the government -- because that's one definition of "socialism." Love you, man.
Ah, yes, the Scarlet A. I guess we have a long history of stigmatizing the unfortunate among us. Who with any ounce of sanity thinks that sonograms should be required by law? Don't we have doctors to determine whether they are medically necessary? I can't help but think this is similar to the situation in Egypt where women were being given virginity tests after being arrested for protesting in the streets of Cairo.
Over the years I have alternately shaken my fists at you for not seeing my side of things and applauded you for "telling it like it is." My verdict on your latest controversy: keep singing the song in the key you think is best. Dude (and I mean Dude in an awkward, trying to sound hipper than I am way), you are awesome. Keep up the good work. This country needs your voice. Thanks for everything!
Whew, lotta noise from this first strip. I guess it will only get noisier. For all the hellfire coming your way please know that this woman is grateful and thankful for your insight and humor on a lousy law bent on shaming and controling women. The anti-choice faction will never relent. Wish they understood that organizations like Planned Parenthood that give access to birth control stop more abortions than they ever will..
As a mother of two wanted and loved children in Virginia, where they recently passed ultrasound legislation, thank you. I appreciate your guts and your support of keeping the government out of my and my daughters' reproductive business. We teach our children that their private parts are private. When the government forces women to accept whatever touching they mandate and that additionally, we should have to pay for that mandate, I think they should remember that such decisions are not theirs to make, but should be left to the privacy usually enjoyed between a woman and her doctor. Thank you for respecting that privacy.
What about the men involved? It takes two to make a pregnancy. Many times when a woman seeks to terminate it's because the man is being irresponsible or downright demanding that she "get rid of it." But nothing happens to the male. I think the man should be charged with child endangerment.
Thank you for illustrating so succinctly how strong the desire is on the part of the radical right to put women in the U.S. in political burkhas.
I am a mother of five with three grown daughters and two daughters-in-law all of child bearing age. Thank you for trying to protect their right to choose when and how and if they start a family by bringing this issue to light for so many. You have a way of explaining things to even the stupid people.
We are supposed to pray for our enemies, so I will pray for you. You are incorrect in your willingness to kill babies (you know, that thing they call "abortion"). The classical type of liberalism calls for the defense of defensless victims. The Nazi mentality is to kill the inconvenient. Abortion is not liberal. The term has been hijacked. I stopped looking at your propaganda years ago.
Thank you so much for addressing this farcical legislation in the manner it deserves. I had a good chuckle. As a victim of childhood sexual abuse, it makes me sick that many Republican politicians believe sticking probes into women's bodies for no medical purpose and against their will is anything other than a traumatic and unconscionable violation.
What is so bad about making a woman look at the sonogram of a baby she is about to legally murder?
Ten years ago I got pregnant by my future ex-husband. He didn’t want children, and we argued for two days before I decided to examine the possibility of termination. I had to travel 150 miles out of state to get out from under a 24-hour waiting period, a decision I made after the receptionist at the local Planned Parenthood looked at me like I was dung when I told her I was there for an abortion consultation. In New York, I asked for and got an intravaginal ultrasound. I’d told the doctor of my great discomfort with what I was considering. We were able to see that what I was carrying was an embryo, that the neural tube had not yet closed, and that there would not be a beating heart for another five to seven days. The ultrasound gave me great peace of mind with respect to my decision not to continue the pregnancy. The proponents of mandatory ultrasound need to consider that it works both ways.
Granted, I have my opinions about the matter at hand, but I still found your treatment of the subject enlightening. I do not read your comics just for their humor. I feel that you bring forth a good argument about what is going on and the absurdity of it. I am pro-life, but some things go too far. This comic did not and I enjoyed it. Kudos.
Bravo for taking up this controversial subject in your poignant and cogent style. Anyone saying controversy does not belong in this media has not been paying attention. We are looking forward to future installments that will help spark continuing healthy and social discourse and pertinent debate focused on the topic.
Your cartoon series comparing an ultrasound to rape has surprisingly been pulled by our very liberal Des Moines Register. Even they know you've gone too far. The shame wand is all yours.
Thank you thank you thank you for having the balls to stick up for women, for saying what needs to be said, for shining a light on what they've tried to keep dark.
Your comic strip appears to be liberal tripe masquerading as entertainment. Much like Bill "the Muppet" Maher.
I for one grew up looking at the comic pages of the newspaper as an escape from reality where you could get a smile, a good laugh, or a fictional story. Now, especially with your comic strip, I have to decide in the first panel or two if I'm even going to finish it. Look, I understand that there are a lot of issues out there that need to be addressed, but do we have to do abortion? I can get that in the rest of the newspaper. I don't need it in my comics which, if you remember, are supposed to bring a smile or a laugh. I think you lost what it is to be a "comic" writer.
I see that you have tackled the government invasion into the private lives of women in the state of Texas. Kudos to you. I do not think that most people realize what an intrusive procedure the sonogram requirement is since the words "intravaginal" are not used in the TX legislation. It was only with the VA attempt that I became aware that this method will be required to meet the TX requirements.
I find it maddening that the party that wants to reduce government intervention into our lives is promoting this. Voices like yours are needed to highlight the absurdity of our elected officials' decisions. I find that the response from Governor Perry's office ("This is not funny. There is nothing comic about this tasteless interpretation...") to reflect the inability of the culture on the right to appreciate satire. I do not read Doonesbury to get my chuckles in the morning but to enlighten me to the absurdities in our midst. You and other satirical writers are desperately needed. I look forward to reading the strip all week and hope that it generates a lot of conversation here in Dallas. Continue on.
Sonograms are an aid to the full understanding of women and others regarding the development of the fetus. Liberals should be in favor of giving consumers more information about critical choices, rather than being Luddites in this technology. The Doonesbury comic strips on the Texas sonogram requirement are a typical stick-your-head-in-the-sand reaction. I have not followed the strip for years because of Garry Trudeau's consistently immature and undeveloped sense of what is the right thing to do.